Justia 10.0 Lawyer Rating - Badge
BBB Accredited Business - Badge
Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb -  Top Attorney Personal Injury - Badge
Avvo Clients Choice 2013 - Personal Injury - Badge
Massachusetts Academy of Trial Attorneys - Badge
Massachusetts Bar Association 1911 - Badge
Best Workers Compensation Expertise - Badge

Attorney William H. Troupe receives favorable Reviewing Board Decision

Troupe Law Office

Attorney William H. Troupe recently received a favorable decision from the DIA Reviewing Board in Boston. The case involved a registered nurse who injured her back while helping to transfer a patient. She began receiving workers’ compensation temporary total disability benefits for approximately five months, at which point the self-insurer reduced her payments to maximum partial disability. The employee, through her counsel, filed a claim at the Department of Industrial Accidents, to get her benefits increased back up to the total disability rate.

Boston skyline

Pursuant to Section 11A of the Workers’ Compensation Act, the employee was examined by an impartial physician. After the hearing, the Judge ultimately adopted the opinion of the impartial physician, who found that the employee was restricted “to work which requires her to be able to change positions frequently and not require sitting of more than 30 minutes at a time, no lifting more than 10 pounds and no more than 4 hours a day.” The Judge was also “persuaded by the employee’s testimony” concerning her subjective complaints of pain. In her decision, the Administrative Judge ultimately awarded the Employee ongoing total disability benefits.

The Self-Insurer appealed the decision on 3 grounds: 1) that the expert medical evidence failed to support a causal relationship between the employee’s work injury and her disability, 2) the judge’s finding that the employee is totally disabled was not supported by the evidence and reasonable inferences therefrom, and 3) the judge failed to consider all of its evidence.

The Reviewing Board rejected the Self-insurers’ arguments. They found that the Judge correctly adopted the opinion of the 11A Impartial Physician and that the Judge acted within her discretion in giving “decisive weight” to the Employee’s subjective complaints of pain. The Reviewing Board also found “harmless error” in the Judge’s failure to list or consider the medical evidence it submitted at conference, which was part of the record. Citing Driscoll v. Town of Framingham, (February 25, 2014)(citation omitted), “misinterpretation of medical opinion rendered harmless when viewed in context of other findings.” The evidence in question, actually supported the Employee’s claim, and therefore, the Reviewing Board found this to be a harmless error.

As such, the favorable decision of the Administrative Judge was affirmed.

Registered Nurses and other nursing staff are among the most common clients we encounter at the Troupe Law Office, as is the mechanism of injury that occurred in this case. Injuries of such can often be career ending, given the physical demands in the nursing profession.

If you have sustained an injury at work, of any kind, it is crucial that you speak with an experienced workers’ compensation attorney as soon as possible. Please visit our web site at https://www.troupelawoffice.com for more information. Or, call us at (978) 531-7401, or email at atroupe@mac.com. We offer free consultations for all cases. We look forward to working with you.

Recent Posts

How Does A Workers Comp Lawyer Get Paid? How Does A Workers Comp Lawyer Get Paid? This is one of the most frequently asked questions posed on the internet regarding workers compensation...

How Does Medical Treatment Get Approved Through The Workers’ Comp System? How Does Medical Treatment Get Approved Through The Workers’ Comp System? This is a highly complicated question with no simple answers, and...

Do I Need A Lawyer To Settle A Workers Comp Claim? Do I Need A Lawyer To Settle A Workers Comp Claim? The short answer is Yes.  That is, if you want to ensure that your rights are adequately...

Client Reviews

Adam and Bill helped me achieve wonderful results of my workers compensation and my accidental disability retirement cases. This was a very complex matter which they handled superbly. Highly recommended attorneys for any workers comp or disability related case.

Mike C.

My overall experience with him was excellent. His overall communication was impeccable especially his ability to explain the law to someone not familiar with legal issues. He always had/made time to pick up the phone. No question was ever too small or insignificant.


In 1992 I was severely injured in a work related accident. It was apparent that my recovery would take years and I needed someone on my side to deal with the insurance company. Attorney Troupe made sure that the Insurance company lived up to their obligations and allowed me to focus on my recovery...


Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 No Fee Unless You Win
  3. 3 Will Travel to You

Fill out the contact form or call us at (978) 531-7401 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message